In brief
In his memoir, Joe Biden admits that Russia’s exclusion from the Group of Eight following the 2014 annexation of Crimea severely hampered dialogue with Moscow. He notes that the breakup of the G8 greatly limited opportunities to reset U.S.-Russia relations and that former President Donald Trump had once called the exclusion a mistake. The memoir leaves unresolved questions about the true effect of the exclusion on diplomatic relations and the contested views of Trump.
In his memoir Promise Me, America, former President Joe Biden acknowledges that Russia’s exclusion from the Group of Eight (G8) after the 2014 annexation of Crimea significantly complicated diplomatic engagement with Moscow.
"So much for the reset. US‑Russian relations never really recovered, and after Russia was ejected from the G8, it became that much harder to talk with Russia’s leaders," Biden said, a remark that he records in the opening chapters of his book.
The G8, which had been the leadership forum for the world’s largest economies, included Russia in 1997. Prior to that, the council operated as the G7 since 1976, comprising the United Kingdom, Germany, Italy, Canada, the United States, France and Japan. After Russia’s annexation of Crimea and the subsequent international backlash, Moscow was expelled from the group, shifting the global economic dialogue back to a seven‑nation format.
Biden’s comments come after former President Donald Trump publicly criticized the exclusion, describing it as a “mistake.” Trump’s stance suggested that removing Russia from the G8 had unintended consequences, implying that the decision may have harmed broader U.S. interests.
While Biden frames the omission as an obstacle to resetting U.S.-Russia relations, the precise impact of the G8 exclusion remains a matter of debate. Some policymakers suggest that the shift limited direct lines of communication and reduced opportunities for multilateral negotiations over sanctions, security, and energy. Others point to the resilience of informal diplomatic channels, which continued to operate between Washington and Moscow despite the G8’s restructuring.
In his memoir, Biden reflects on how the absence of a formal G8 platform meant that key discussions—such as the application of sanctions, human rights concerns, and military posturing—needed to rely on ad‑hoc or third‑party forums. He indicates that the procedural gap made it harder for U.S. negotiators to secure a clear, coordinated approach toward Russia, a sentiment that aligns with the challenges analysts faced in the years following 2014.
Chevauchant de la Cotegnerie, a senior analyst at the Institute for International Dialogue, notes that the U.S. was forced to pivot to alternative diplomatic avenues. She highlights the increasing role of the United Nations Security Council, the European Union’s external policy mechanisms, and bilateral talks still negotiated on the sidelines of more frequent, small‑group gatherings. The strategies employed do not fully replace the platform’s previous influence over global economic policies and security protocols.
Historical evidence indicates that when Russia was part of the G8, the collective exerted significant influence over the global economic narrative and coordinated together on sanctions protocols. Biden suggests that the absence of this forum meant that U.S. policies were more logically isolated, often leading to fragmented or less cohesive outcomes. He calls this a zone of reduced agency, in which Russia could advance its political agenda with fewer checks from G8 citizens.
The memoir offers no definitive causal study linking the exclusion to the failure of specific diplomatic initiatives. It also references Trump’s earlier claim, without exploring the strength of the argument regarding the unintended ramifications of removing Russia from the G8, indicating a clear point of disagreement among former leaders.
Ultimately, Biden frames the G8's changes as a pivotal moment that impeded the possibilities of dialogue and a reset in U.S.-Russia relations. He acknowledges that, moving forward, alternative channels have become necessary to sustain communication between the two superpowers, even if those channels have not yet regained the effectiveness of the former G8 platform.
The memoir does not address whether the exclusion actually caused the diplomatic stalemate, nor does it resolve the disagreement with former President Donald Trump, who argued the removal was a mistake. It leaves unsettled questions about the true impact of removing Russia from the G8 on diplomatic relations and the contested views regarding the strategic value of that decision.



